Axe ’Em, Jacks!
There is no one way to do undergraduate research/creative discovery, but what all undergraduate research experiences have in common is that they give students firsthand experience in the process of creating knowledge. Your learning objective should guide you in choosing the form and intensity of an undergraduate research experience.
You Can Choose the Form
Undergraduate research/creative discovery projects can take many forms. Here are some examples:
- Class-based activities, like naturalistic observation, surveys, quantitative writing assignments and experiments, can often be structured to walk students through the steps of the research process.
- Class-based projects, like term papers, service learning, and community-based and campus-based learning, can be of a research nature.
- Capstone experiences like senior research projects and honors research experiences can allow students to develop and explore a research question of their own.
- Out-of-class student/faculty-mentored research/creative discovery, like summer research experiences, provide opportunities for students to work alongside a faculty member on ongoing research or on a project designed by both.
You Can Choose the Intensity
You can choose the intensity of an undergraduate research and creative discovery experience. Consider the following:
Breadth versus depth
You can create an experience in which you engage students lightly in all aspects of the research process, or you can offer an opportunity for students to engage in a more in-depth investigation of a research question or creative discovery. For the former, a class-based activity or project may be best. For the latter, maybe a capstone experience or out-of-class experience is better.
Elements to control
The elements controlled by the student and by the professor (question addressed, data collection methods, location of project, etc.) can differ by project. Some of these elements (like project location) you can make decisions about now. Others you can consider now and refine your thoughts later in the planning process when you structure the critical elements of your students' experiences.
Length of experience
The experience can be a short exercise completed during a single class period, or it can be a multiweek, semester-long, yearlong or an even longer project.
Level of student and course
Light exposure to undergraduate research and creative discovery through a class-based activity may be best in a lower-level course, whereas deeper experiences are better for higher-level courses. Smaller, less intense and more guided projects in lower-level classes can help prepare students for deeper experiences later on.
Works in progress, including your own
Some research and creative discovery projects obviously can't be started and finished in the course of a semester. That's not a reason to not try undergraduate research. Students can learn and contribute by participating in a work-in-progress, even your own. For out-of-class student/faculty mentored projects, sometimes students with less background can shadow faculty and students with more background, preparing themselves for deeper research and creative discovery experiences later on.
Level of collaboration and mentoring
Different projects require different levels of mentoring and collaboration, and you'll want to consider the levels you are willing and able to provide when deciding what is best for you and your students.
Let Your Learning Objectives Guide You
When deciding on the form and intensity of an undergraduate research experience, let your learning objectives guide you. Knowing what they are can make the task of planning and implementing undergraduate research and creative discovery less daunting.
Draw from Other Pedagogical Practices
When planning the nature of your undergraduate research or creative discovery experience, you may discover it's possible to draw from many other respected pedagogical practices you already use.
Information from https://serc.carleton.edu/introgeo/studentresearch/forms_UR.html